← Back to Blog

Fiberglass vs. Cellulose vs. Mineral Wool vs. Foam: The Real Comparison

Every insulation material has strengths and weaknesses. There's no single best choice for every application. The right insulation depends on where it's going, what performance you need, your budget, and your climate. Here's an honest comparison.

Fiberglass Batts

R-value: 3.2-3.8 per inch. The most common insulation in residential construction. Affordable, widely available, and easy to install. But installation quality matters enormously — gaps, compressions, and voids dramatically reduce performance. A perfectly installed fiberglass batt performs well. A typical installation with gaps and compressions can perform 30-50% below its rated R-value. Fiberglass doesn't stop air movement and provides zero moisture management.

Blown Fiberglass

R-value: 2.5-3.7 per inch (varies by density). Blown fiberglass fills cavities more completely than batts, reducing gaps and voids. Dense-pack blown fiberglass (at 2.2+ lbs/cu ft) resists air movement reasonably well. It's excellent for attic floors and can be netted into wall cavities. Less itchy to work with than batts. Settles slightly over time in vertical applications.

Cellulose

R-value: 3.5-3.8 per inch. Made from recycled paper treated with fire retardants (borate). Dense-pack cellulose (3.5 lbs/cu ft in walls) is an excellent air retarder — it fills every void and gap, significantly reducing air leakage even without a separate air barrier. It handles moisture better than fiberglass, absorbing and releasing water vapor without losing performance. The borate treatment provides mold and pest resistance. Excellent value.

Build Your Own House? 42-page guide • 27 construction steps • 40+ years of field-tested knowledge
Get the Guide — $29

Mineral Wool (Rock Wool)

R-value: 3.7-4.2 per inch. Made from volcanic rock or slag. Fire-resistant up to 2,000°F — won't burn, melt, or produce toxic smoke. Excellent sound attenuation. Hydrophobic — repels water rather than absorbing it. More rigid than fiberglass, so batts hold shape better in cavities. Available in semi-rigid boards for exterior continuous insulation. More expensive than fiberglass but offers superior fire, sound, and moisture performance.

Rigid Foam (XPS, EPS, Polyiso)

XPS: R-5 per inch, moisture-resistant, moderate cost. EPS: R-3.8-4.2 per inch, least expensive foam, most permeable. Polyiso: R-5.7-6.5 per inch (but performance drops in cold temperatures). All rigid foams work as continuous exterior insulation to eliminate thermal bridging. They can also serve as air barriers when seams are taped. Polyiso is best for walls; XPS is best below grade where moisture resistance matters.

Spray Foam

Closed-cell: R-6.5-7 per inch. Open-cell: R-3.5-3.7 per inch. Spray foam excels at air sealing — it fills every gap and crack as it expands. Closed-cell also adds structural rigidity and is a vapor retarder. But spray foam is 2-4x the cost of other insulation types, and improper installation (off-ratio mixing) causes callbacks. Best used strategically in hard-to-insulate areas rather than whole-house.

The Smart Approach

Use each insulation where it performs best. Dense-pack cellulose in walls for air sealing and value. Mineral wool for fire-rated assemblies, exterior CI, and sound control. Spray foam at rim joists and irregular cavities. Blown fiberglass or cellulose in attic floors. Rigid foam for sub-slab, below-grade, and exterior continuous insulation. Matching the right product to each application beats using one product everywhere.

Ready to Build Smarter?

Get the complete 42-page owner-builder guide — 27 construction steps from a builder with 40+ years experience and 1,000+ homes.

Get the Guide — $29
★★★★★
"I've built two houses now using this program. The second one went so smooth my bank inspector asked who my GC was. I said 'me.'"
— Carl N., Knoxville, TN

Free Building Tips — Straight to Your Inbox

Get practical construction advice from a builder with 40+ years and 1,000+ homes. No spam, ever.