Change orders are where contractors lose the most money and relationships. Scope creep, poorly documented changes, disputes over pricing—it's chaos. Here's how to manage them cleanly.
Prevent Them First
The best change order is the one you don't have to do. Before you start, have crystal-clear scope documents: What's included. What's not. What costs extra. When homeowners know exactly what to expect, requests for changes drop dramatically.
Document Everything
When a homeowner requests something outside the scope, pause. Don't start work or commit to a price verbally. Create a written change order with:
- Clear description of the requested change
- Additional cost (labor + materials)
- Any timeline impact
- Your signature and the homeowner's signature
No signature, no work. This isn't being difficult—it's being professional.
How to Price Changes
Your cost + markup. If the job is fixed-price at $50K, and a change order adds $2,000 in labor and materials at your standard markup (let's say 30%), the change order price is $2,600.
Don't undersell change orders. This is where your profit lives. If the main job is tight, change orders keep you healthy.
The Homeowner Who Negotiates Every Change
Some will argue about every change order price. Stick to your guns. You calculated it fairly based on actual costs and standard markup. If they want a lower price, the trade-off is timeline or quality—which do they prefer?
Scope Creep Red Flags
"While you're in there..." This precedes scope creep. Charge for it.
"Just a small adjustment." Small changes add up. Document and charge.
"The inspector said we should..." That's a change. Document it. If it's code-related and your responsibility, you absorb it. If it's a homeowner request or unforeseen condition, it's a change order.
Disputed Changes
If a homeowner refuses to pay for a documented change order, you have a paper trail. Don't start the next phase of work. Pause the job and resolve it. Continuing work while the issue festers is a recipe for a messy dispute.
Communications Approach
Frame change orders as protection for both of you: "I want to make sure we're aligned on scope and cost before I do the work. This change order documents exactly what we're doing and the cost. Once you sign, we're set."
Professional contractors use change orders. It shows you're organized and clear.
Change Order Templates
Create a simple template: project name, date, description, cost breakdown, timeline impact, signature lines. Use it for every change. Consistency builds trust.
The Bottom Line
Change orders are normal. Handle them professionally—document, price fairly, and get signatures—and they're profit opportunities. Ignore them or handle them casually, and they become relationship disasters.